School districts in crisis; low growth expected in 2012
By PA Independent Staff
HARRISBURG — Lawmakers returned here this week for the first time in 2012 and want to make the passage of a Marcellus shale impact fee and regulation bill the No. 1 issue before Gov. Tom Corbett’s budget address in February.
Other areas of state government also are looking ahead to the budget battle, looming this spring.
Financial projections from the state’s new Independent Fiscal Office confirmed the Corbett administration’s concerns that Pennsylvania might have to make further cuts to keep spending in line with revenue, though some economic growth is expected.
And school districts, particularly the poorest ones that rely the most on state tax dollars to function, could be heading toward crisis as budgets continue to grow even as students leave.
Local concerns over state drilling bill
A proposal allowing the state Attorney General’s Office to bring lawsuits against municipalities that attempt to ban natural gas drilling drew protesters, as lawmakers continue to negotiate on a Marcellus shale policy package.
This issue is one of several a
joint House and Senate Conference Committee must sort through this month, after the state House and Senate could not work out differences on separate bills to create a natural gas drilling impact fee and updated safety, environmental and zoning regulations.
The six-member committee — two legislators each from the House and Senate majorities as well as one from each body’s minority — has not been formed yet. Negotiations continue behind-closed-doors between House and Senate leaders.
The Marcellus shale drilling legislation “is bad legislation,” said Maria Payan, a York County resident who attended a rally Tuesday on the steps of the Capitol rotunda. “This bill would prevent citizens from passing laws to protect their own health and safety.”
“The Attorney General is the appropriate office to handle these issues, because that office is supposed to be above reproach, and there is nothing wrong with the attorney general calling balls and strikes,” said
Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, a member of the conference committee and sponsor of the Senate bill.
Scarnati, one of the architects of the natural gas bills being debated in the General Assembly, wants to have the final package passed before the new budget process begins in February.
School district faces financial crisis due to mismanagement
State Department of Education Secretary Ron Tomalis and
Gov. Tom Corbett said they believe the
Chester Upland School Board has mismanaged the district and are determined to stop pouring more state dollars into the
Delaware County district.
The Chester Upland district and its solicitor, Robin Bush, are not talking publicly about the matter.
Since 2003, the school district has received nearly $31 million in financial assistance above what the state was required to provide. Between June 2010 and March 2011, the district received $9.5 million in special funding over what was provided for in traditional state funding, according to the Department of Education.
In an exclusive interview with the
PA Independent this week, Tomalis said his department advanced $16.35 million in basic education funding last year, so the district could satisfy its financial obligations, avoid default on loan payments and continue operating.
“The department’s unprecedented financial support and technical assistance were extraordinary measures to assist the district in its ability to ensure continued operations,” Tomalis said. “However, they were not a permanent solution for financial recovery.”
Democratic lawmakers are putting pressure on the administration to make more emergency funds available to the district, which Tomalis said will be given enough aid to make it to the end of this school year.
Redistricting cases face conflict of interest in court
A potential conflict of interest on the state Supreme Court could throw a monkey wrench into the final step of Pennsylvania’s legislative redistricting process and leave voters without knowing their districts when the election process begins next week.
A petition, filed with the state Supreme Court by a
Berks County resident, seeks to disqualify
Justice Joan Orie Melvin from Monday’s hearing on the new state House and Senate district maps. The complaint alleges a conflict of interest, because Orie Melvin’s decision would determine the new legislative district for her sister, state
Sen. Jane Orie, R-Allegheny.
The complaint, filed by Dennis Baylor of Hamburg, refers to the Pennsylvania Code of Judicial Conduct, which tells judges to “perform the duties of their office impartially and diligently.”
The code also requires that judges “should uphold the integrity and independence of the judiciary” and “refrain from political activity inappropriate to their judicial office.”
The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments on the challenges Monday in the state Capitol, the day before the first step in the state’s primary election process begins with the circulation of nominating petitions.
Legal experts said judges at all levels typically recuse themselves from cases involving family members. This principle should extend to a judge deciding a legislative district for a family member, but a formal process for determining a conflict of interest in this situation does not exist.
Orie Melvin is also the target of a grand jury investigation and her sister is awaiting trial on charges that she used her state Senate office and resources to help get Orie Melvin elected to the state’s highest court in 2008.
New Fiscal Office makes first projections
Pennsylvania should see moderate economic growth as unemployment figures remain mostly the same this year, according to projections by the state’s new
Independent Fiscal Office.
The new office is intended to provide an assessment of economic, demographic, revenue and expenditure trends, which they said will affect Pennsylvania’s fiscal condition over the next five years.
Independent Fiscal Office Director
Matthew Knittel, a former senior economist with the
U.S. Department of Treasury,said the Great Recession is expected to continue to restrain economic growth, and state unemployment figures are expected to hold at its current 7.9 percent throughout the year.
Fiscal Office projections, which used the current fiscal year as a base as well as revenue from taxes and other sources, showed that real economic growth would remain modest at 1.6 percent for the commonwealth for 2012. Real growth should peak in the state in 2014 at 3.2 percent, while unemployment should dip to 7.1 percent in 2014, according to projections.
Voucher battle is 15 years in the making
School choice is advancing in Pennsylvania, even as a public school voucher plan remains stuck in legislative limbo.
But while vouchers get most of the ink — as they have since they were first proposed by Gov. Tom Ridge in 1996 — the educational options available to Pennsylvania families today have expanded dramatically in 20 years.
Pennsylvania boasts a robust charter school system that includes cyber charter schools; the Education Improvement Tax Credit, or EITC, which provides an average scholarship of $1,000 to low-income families who want their children to attend private schools; and rules that allow parents to teach their students at home.
The key is to improve education options, said Ken Kilpatrick, spokesman for the Pennsylvania Coalition of Public Charter Schools, which represents charter schools in the state.
“It’s families making a choice about what school will give (their) child the best educational future,” Kilpatrick said. “Competition is forcing districts to think about how they can improve.”